Keeping Passion At Bay
Keeping Passion At Bay
By Dick Morris
President Bush will succeed in his Social Security changes because he has skillfully drafted them in such a way that the only voters who are affected support his proposal while the ones who oppose it won't be affected by it.
Pollster Scott Rasmussen reports that support for private investment skews dramatically by age group. Those aged 18 to 29 back it by 65 percent to 22 percent. Thirtysomething voters support it by 63-28; those in their 40s, 59-30.
But voters between the ages of 50 and 64 oppose the private-investment option by 49-41, and those over 65, by 63-27.
So the only voters who oppose private investment are those whom the reforms won't touch. Those for whom the changes are real, generally support them.
So Bush has succeeded in anesthetizing the Social Security debate: His proposed changes will stir passion only in the breasts of ideologues of each stripe, but not in the voters most affected.
Which means his program is likely to pass despite dire Democratic warnings.
The stakes here could not be higher for the political parties. The ideologues care deeply, on both sides of the fence.
Democrats are deeply, sincerely suspicious about the Republicans' motives. President Clinton once told me that the Republicans want to eliminate any middle-class entitlements. He said that they sought to restrict any federal benefit programs only to the poor so that they can slash them with political impunity. He said that the GOP feared any program that benefited the middle class because it gave the government and therefore the Democrats who push these programs power over swing voters.
This fear impelled Clinton to battle against medical savings accounts, pushed by the Republicans as an alternative health-care reform. And now it leads the Democrats to fret over the personal retirement accounts Bush would establish.
It is not that these programs are likely to fail. Democrats fear them because they suspect that they will succeed that government-run Social Security will henceforth only be for those so poor that they could not amass much in their retirement accounts. (You would have to earn over $50,000 per year for the 4 percent of income you would be allowed to divert to these accounts to reach the $2,000 annual ceiling specified in the Bush proposal).
Once Social Security becomes only for the poor, the Democrats fear, it will be fair game for Republican budget cutters.
The Republicans, meanwhile, look at Europe and worry that middle-class entitlements will make voters dependent on the government. They fear that we will become like France, where everyone gets a government check and, therefore, nobody minds paying high taxes or will let the government cut the subsidies. They see the Bush plan reducing American voters' government dependency, making our electorate even more self-reliant.
So the debate taps deeply into the core ideals and phobias of each party.
Yet the entire rest of the nation is likely to greet Bush's plan with relative equanimity. By avoiding the Reagan trap of seeking to cut benefits for existing retirees and even exempting those now over 55 from any change Bush has relegated the changes to the realm of theory for most voters. For most of these younger voters, retirement is a far-off thing and their confidence in their own ability to play the markets runs deep.
Democrats will rant and rave. But they won't find any mass constituency for their passion and the program will pass.
Bush could still get shipwrecked by the cuts he proposes in benefits to avoid bankruptcy. But his privatization proposal should pass easily.
Dick Morris was an adviser to Bill Clinton for 20 years. Look for Dicks new book "Because He Could" about Bill Clinton. Copyright 2005 Dick Morris, All Rights Reserved. Distributed by Cagle Cartoons, Inc. www.caglecartoons.com Call Cari Dawson Bartley at (800) 696 7561 or e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org email for Dick Morris is email@example.com
RESTRICTIONS: Dick Morris' columns may not be reprinted in New York City, in Washington D.C., and in media owned by the AOL Time Warner.
Download Dick Morris and Eileen McGann's color photo - Download Dick Morris and Eileen McGann's black and white mug shot photo
|Why not run a cartoon with the column? We recommend the cartoons below as a good compliment to Dick Morris and Eileen McGann's topic.|
Click on the thumbnail images to preview and download the cartoons.
Social Security Bikini
By: Mike Lane
January 17, 2005
The lock box
By: Larry Wright
February 3, 2005
By: Mike Lester
The Rome News-Tribune
January 26, 2005
| || |
We do not accept and will not review unsolicited submissions from cartoonists.
Sales & Information: (805) 969-2829 firstname.lastname@example.org
Billing Information: (805) email@example.com
Technical Support: firstname.lastname@example.org
FREE cartoons for your website if you're already a paying print subscriber!